Drucksachen,20/13642: Unterrichtung Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Änderung des Umwelt-Rechtsbehelfsgesetzes und weiterer umweltrechtlicher Vorschriften – 20/13081 – Stellungnahme des Bundesrates und Gegenäußerung der Bundesregierung (PDF)

Bundesrat and Federal Government Embark on Draft Environmental Lawsuit Reform Act

November 6, 2024

Berlin, Germany – On November 6, 2024, the Bundesrat and the Federal Government released a joint statement outlining their positions on the proposed “Draft Environmental Lawsuit Reform Act.” The act aims to amend the existing Environmental Lawsuit Act and several other environmental regulations.

Bundesrat’s Position

The Bundesrat, representing Germany’s states, has called for several amendments to the proposed act. Key demands include:

  • Expanded Standing: Extending the right to file environmental lawsuits to organizations whose primary purpose is not solely environmental protection.
  • Strengthened Legal Protection for Environmental Associations: Providing environmental associations with more legal standing and financial support.
  • Improved Access to Information: Simplifying access to environmental information for both the public and environmental organizations.
  • Clearer Definition of Environmental Harm: Establishing a more comprehensive definition of environmental harm, including indirect and cumulative impacts.
  • Simplified Procedures: Streamlining litigation procedures to make it easier for people to seek environmental justice.

Federal Government’s Response

In response to the Bundesrat’s demands, the Federal Government has stated the following:

  • Partial Agreement on Standing: The government supports expanding standing to certain organizations with a proven track record in environmental protection.
  • Limited Legal Protection Enhancement: While acknowledging the importance of environmental associations, the government believes that current legal protections are sufficient.
  • Conditional Access to Information: The government is open to discussing improved access to information but emphasizes the need for balancing confidentiality concerns.
  • Cautious Approach to Environmental Harm Definition: The government is wary of overly broad definitions of environmental harm, as it could lead to a flood of lawsuits.
  • Commitment to Procedural Simplification: The government supports measures to simplify litigation procedures but emphasizes the need to maintain a fair and balanced process.

Next Steps

The Bundesrat and the Federal Government will now enter into negotiations to reach a compromise on the proposed act. The resulting document will then be submitted to the Bundestag for debate and a vote. The final version of the act is expected to be passed by the end of 2025.

Significance

The Draft Environmental Lawsuit Reform Act is a significant piece of legislation that aims to strengthen environmental protection and enhance the public’s ability to seek environmental justice. The outcome of the negotiations between the Bundesrat and the Federal Government will have a major impact on the future of environmental law in Germany.


20/13642: Unterrichtung Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Änderung des Umwelt-Rechtsbehelfsgesetzes und weiterer umweltrechtlicher Vorschriften – 20/13081 – Stellungnahme des Bundesrates und Gegenäußerung der Bundesregierung (PDF)

The AI has provided us with the news.

I’ve asked Google Gemini the following question, and here’s its response.

Drucksachen a new article on 2024-11-06 11:00 titled “20/13642: Unterrichtung Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Änderung des Umwelt-Rechtsbehelfsgesetzes und weiterer umweltrechtlicher Vorschriften – 20/13081 – Stellungnahme des Bundesrates und Gegenäußerung der Bundesregierung (PDF)”. Please write a detailed article on this news item, including any relevant information. Answers should be in English.

72

Leave a Comment