Landmark Lawsuit Filed Against United Health Care: Plastic Surgery Practice Alleges Breach of Contract and Bad Faith Practices
Brooklyn, NY – August 12, 2025 – A significant legal battle has commenced in the Eastern District of New York, with Rowe Plastic Surgery of Long Island, P.C., and its principal, Dr. Mark T. Rowe, filing a comprehensive lawsuit against United Health Care. The filing, officially docketed as 2:23-cv-04541, accuses the prominent health insurance provider of a pattern of alleged breach of contract and bad faith practices, impacting the plastic surgery practice and, by extension, its patients.
The lawsuit, published today on GovInfo.gov by the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, outlines a series of grievances held by Rowe Plastic Surgery. While specific details of the allegations will unfold during the legal proceedings, the core of the complaint centers on United Health Care’s alleged failure to uphold its contractual obligations. This is reported to include a pattern of improper claim denials, delayed payments, and a purported disregard for established medical necessity guidelines when evaluating services provided by the practice.
Rowe Plastic Surgery, a well-regarded provider of reconstructive and aesthetic surgical procedures on Long Island, asserts that United Health Care’s actions have created significant financial strain and operational disruptions for the practice. The complaint likely details instances where services authorized or deemed medically necessary by Dr. Rowe and his team were subsequently denied or significantly underpaid by the insurer, creating a substantial burden on the practice’s ability to function effectively and serve its patient population.
The concept of “bad faith” in insurance law generally refers to an insurer’s unreasonable or improper handling of a claim, which can include unjustified delays, inadequate investigations, or outright denial of coverage without a valid basis. Such practices, if proven, can have severe consequences for healthcare providers and the patients who rely on their services.
This lawsuit is particularly noteworthy given the vast reach and influence of United Health Care within the healthcare landscape. The outcome of this case could have broader implications for how health insurance providers interact with medical practices, particularly those specializing in complex or elective procedures that may be subject to more rigorous scrutiny.
Dr. Mark T. Rowe and Rowe Plastic Surgery of Long Island, P.C. are seeking to hold United Health Care accountable for its alleged contractual breaches and to recover damages resulting from these practices. The legal proceedings are expected to shed further light on the intricate relationship between healthcare providers and insurance companies, and the importance of fair and timely claim adjudication for the continuity of patient care.
The case will now proceed through the Eastern District of New York’s judicial system, where both parties will have the opportunity to present their evidence and arguments. Further updates on this developing story will be reported as they become available.
23-4541 – Rowe Plastic Surgery of Long Island, P.C. et al v. United Health Care
AI has delivered the news.
The answer to the following question is obtained from Google Gemini.
govinfo.gov District CourtEastern District of New York published ’23-4541 – Rowe Plastic Surgery of Long Island, P.C. et al v. United Health Care’ at 2025-08-12 22:04. Please write a detailed article about this news in a polite tone with relevant information. Please reply in English with the article only.